Awaiting decision meaning journal

Awaiting decision meaning journal. It would most probably be only one. Don’t fabricate or falsify data/results. The status “'Awaiting AE evaluation'” means that that the peer review has been completed and now the Assigned Editor (AE) will consider the feedback provided by the peer reviewers and arrives at a decision. I was asked to resubmit the paper with modifications within a month. So, the status of my paper was "Awaiting reviewer scores" since one month and it turned to "Awaiting editorial decision" last Friday. After two months, it changed to “awaiting recommendation” status. It means the editor, an associate editor or a handling editor will have a look and make a decision. The paper may also be returned to the Sep 16, 2021 · For example, you may request that the journal examine the issue in detail and, if you’re right, to rescind the editor’s decision because the existence of such an incorrect accusation in the journal’s record may harm your reputation and career in ways that you cannot imagine or expect. Stages of Peer Review from Submission to Accept/Reject Decision. However, today, it changed back to Awaiting Referee Scores. Manuscript submitted: This means that the manuscript has been successfully submitted and approved by the author. Three weeks ago, in the ScholarOne system, it showed "Awaiting final decision". Now the review status changed to "Awaiting RE Decision" . Under review also can mean that the article is being considered by the science editor for technical and English language check or it is with the subject editor and he is evaluating it for external review, or the article is Feb 18, 2022 · Awaiting Reviewer Scores. From the change of status above, does it mean that the AE rejects the paper and then send it to the EiC to Apr 21, 2020 · Meaning of ‘Awaiting Editor Assignment’ This means that your manuscript has cleared the admin check, that is, it was found matching the journal’s scope and also adhering to the journal’s guidelines, apart from a cursory check of the novelty and quality of the study. For the first week of submission, the status was "with editor" and then it changed to under review for one week, then reviewers asigned Aug 24, 2021 · Q: Awaiting EIC decision after major revision. Next, suitable referees are selected based Jun 13, 2018 · Journals usually have standard status changes like 'Under editorial processing,' 'Under review,' 'Decision pending,' 'Decision in process,' etc. Feb 5, 2022 · Check with Journal, they usually provide statistics as to what is their average decision time. A rejection at this (or the previous) stage is called desk reject. C. the employee of the publisher assigned to the journal) or the editor-in-chief assigns an editorial board member to handle the paper. This means the initial check on the manuscript is complete, which means that the Editor-in-Chief (EiC) and/or the Associate Editor (AE) believe/s the manuscript fulfills basic journal criteria such as novelty of the research, quality Feb 26, 2021 · Awaiting Reviewer Assignment means the journal editor has started reaching out to potential reviewers for your manuscript. If your manuscript is at this stage, then enough experts have agreed to read and evaluate it and we just need to wait for the reviewers to return their comments so that a decision can be taken. Now, this status has remained for 18 days. :) So, you could wait a week or so. But how does the editor actually take the decision on a manuscript? This article explains the sequence of events that lead from peer review to editorial decision making: how the AE procures the completed reviews, assesses them, and finally comes to a decision on whether to accept the manuscript, request Apr 23, 2020 · Two days after submitting my manuscript, I saw the status changing from ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ to ‘Awaiting EiC Decision. I was thrilled because I thought that might mean I'll get an answer quite soon. I submitted my research article to T&F journal. What does it mean? The status of another manuscript is "ED: Freestone, Mark, GE: Not Assigned, and Awaiting Reviewer Selection. As per my understanding, the status should be Awaiting EIC Decision. Oct 6, 2021 · 1 Answer to this question. The day after the submission though, the two statuses of ‘Awaiting Final Decision’ and ‘Awaiting Reviewer Decision’ were displayed together. Cite. Mar 9, 2022 · The editorial hierarchy varies from journal to journal. Jul 1, 2020 · The EiC/EC makes the final decision on the manuscript. What does this mean? What does the 'SE' stand for? Why is the decision to be made by the SE classified as "preliminary"? Will there by further non-preliminary decisions made at the editorial office? Sep 15, 2020 · So, you should wait for the next decision. Once initial check up is done on your manuscript, the EIC will screen your manuscript to check if it fits the scope of the journal and if it is of sufficient interest to the journal's readership. The editor also evaluates the peer review reports and makes a final decision. Eic usually signifies the Editor in chief. I have done a submission to other journal some months before and the "with editor" process was just a Jul 12, 2022 · The statuses on submission portals change based on the journal's processes in real-time. IEEE Access has a typical acceptance rate of about 30%, which is . Revise. Paper status indicators include: I submitted an article in a scientific journal, after verification by the editor the status is changed (Awaiting Reviewer Scores), then after a month and a half, the status is changed again Nov 1, 2019 · Awaiting EIC decision must have appeared after the first status while you did not check your status! It Appearing after short interval of awaiting reviewer assignment clearly means that associate editors have advised against it! Now the EIC has to make decision. Nov 12, 2020 · The next day, it changed to ‘Awaiting Decision Approval. IEEE Access strives to maintain an expedited peer review process of only 4 to 6 weeks, however, all article submissions still undergo a thorough peer review process to ensure only high-quality articles are published. My manuscript had earlier gone through English proofreading by a professional vendor. Awaiting Editor Decision. k. Mar 16, 2022 · Answer: Dear Author, Thank you for your question. Unfortunately I looked Sep 18, 2020 · I have submitted a manuscript to a pediatrics-related journal. Jan 8, 2021 · So, based on when all are back and available for the final check, the status will change and the manuscript move to the final review stage. There are several decisions that authors may receive after submitting their paper to one of the Society’s journals: Reject without review: The Action Editor has rejected the paper without sending it for peer review. The status, "Awaiting ED decision" most likely indicates that the manuscript is with the journal editor (likely editor-in-chief) for final checks before you receive the verdict. 6. The peer review process When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. Thus, the status also reflects "Awaiting Reviewer Scores". So, its status is "Awaiting Decision". This could be another reason for the swift movement from submission to the ED/EIC decision – as this is a shorter piece. Dec 19, 2020 · At times, the changes may be initiated by the platform itself. Subscribe and get curated content that will give impetus to your research paper. 2 Recommendations. It also helps you understand the difference between being patient and waiting too long, identify situations when you should raise a query, and tells you how often Feb 18, 2014 · "First look" is a stage in the ScholarOne Manuscripts (S1M) system used by many journals. The final decision - whether to accept or reject the paper - depends on the reviewer scores, which is why the status of your manuscript would Sep 6, 2021 · Here is a possible interpretation: the paper might have received the comments of all of its reviewers. Check out this question. , conflicting opinions in those comments, has sent the paper to another reviewer. If they are well past their normal decision times, you should inquire about your submission status. (ScholarOne makes regular updates to their platform, once every two or three months. Decision notification e-mails and what they mean. You will see what each decision type is and what it means for you and your article. This stage could be called as "Awaiting AE assignment", wherein the manuscript is evaluated for ethical considerations and scope match with the readership of the journal. I submitted my manuscript to a journal from 1 month ago in scholar one. The current status of your manuscript indicates that your paper is with the editor, and he/she is evaluating your manuscript to arrive at a decision. If the paper contains too many errors or problems for the referees to comment fully on the scientific content, the authors will be asked to make corrections and then resubmit the article. The EiC gives the final verdict based on the AE's recommendation. Last week, the status changed to Awaiting AE Recommendation. (For most journals, the associate editor is referred to as the AE. Dec 4, 2018 · This, in turn, means that the status "Awaiting decision" refers to the decision that the editor will take about whether your paper will be sent for peer review or desk rejected. , because it does not fit the journal’s scope or requirements on importance or quality. g. Jul 9, 2019 · 1. Under 'Awaiting AE Preliminary Decision', you will the list of papers for which you can draft a decision. " I do understand that probably the editor required one more I sent a submission to an Elsevier Journal. According to the process described in IEEE Transactions, "Awaiting AE recommendation" status means that the AE has collected all reviews from the reviewers who were assigned to review your manuscript and that the AE's decision for acceptance is pending. It is difficult to predict the outcome of the manuscript at this stage, but you can be hopeful. Jun 12, 2020 · These stand for the associate editor and guest editor respectively. After this step, you're likely to receive a decision of acceptance with major/minor revisions (fingers Apr 12, 2016 · Dear Editage Insights team, I submitted my article 3 months ago to a journal. The following are the most common decisions that are made: Hope this answers your question. However, irrespective of the outcome, the AE's decision should not have been this delayed. Accept - No further revision required. As per my personal experience with IOP Journal (s), the status "Awaiting Referee Report" implies that the reviewers are already assigned and review work is in-progress. “Awaiting SE Recommendation” means that it went to a Section Editor (SE) of the journal for checking the match with that section of the journal. So more than 1 month is definitely atypical, and you should write in and ask. The ‘decision in process’ status implies that your manuscript has passed through peer review and the editorial board is now making a decision. ‘Revision’ here could mean that your manuscript requires further revisions to be accepted. So, you should know the first decision on the paper soon. 1. Answer: Thank you for your question! When a manuscript is submitted, it undergoes editorial assessment. Mar 6, 2021 · “Awaiting decision” is not incompatible with “All reviewer report received” or “Editorial Assessment”. Awaiting Reviewer Selection , which is the next stage, means that the editor has received responses from multiple peer reviewers and is presently in the process of making a selection among them. The Editor has made a decision and requested you revise the submission. This status will remain until you begin the process of submitting your revision. or. 2. Awaiting Admin Processing: Your submission is waiting for initial review by the editorial office. Scenario 1: with editor/under editor evaluation >> awaiting reviewer selection >> under review If this is how the status had changed the first time you submitted the paper, then chances are that your paper is actually being sent for a re-review. Ajit Singh. Jul 30, 2021 · I submitted a manuscript to a scientific journal. Instruction for authors) and that figures are of sufficient quality (resolution for bitmaps). Regards, Cite Nov 4, 2020 · Hello Eisa – Welcome to the forum. Understand the journal and case study peer review process and read our tips for revising your submission. After a week the status changed to “Under Review”. Either the desk editor (i. 3. Oct 24, 2020 · A direct change after submission (or after the initial admin check) to ‘Awaiting AE Recommendation’ typically means that the Associate Editor (AE) has had a look at the paper and decided not to send it for review. The ‘Assigning Reviewers’ status here and the quick change from it probably Jul 19, 2019 · I have submitted my paper to an IET journal. Peer review is the process used to assess whether an academic paper is suitable for publication based on the quality, originality and importance of the work. Minor Revision - A limited number of changes are required. It it is desk reject, then reviewer means the editor herself. Status Specific Categories Immediate Decision. Since they seem to be updating, albeit slowly, I would consider you to enhance your patience. Learn the meanings of statuses and the average time taken at each stage, along with detailed descriptions of the many statuses from submission to first decision and final decision. Nov 19, 2020 · One factor for this could be that they now believe your journal would fit better with a related or partner journal. But the editor, for some reason, e. Texas A&M University-Commerce. Oct 27, 2023 · Meaning: Manuscript Submitted: This means the author has successfully submitted and approved the manuscript. Cheers, Frank. Aug 11, 2021 · Improve the chances of your manuscript’s acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. e. The GE, as the name suggests, is an external editor and is assigned when the journal cannot find an Apr 28, 2022 · When the decision is finalized, you will receive a direct email with the overall editorial decision, Editor and/or reviewer comments, and further instructions. The manuscript is publishable in its current form. (Note that for some journals, this could mean the AE review, but again, here, it does seem that the manuscript is being checked by the peer reviewers. ’ What does this mean? Mar 15, 2016 · Once a paper is submitted to a journal, authors eagerly wait for the editorial decision. It is possible that these are minor Sep 14, 2019 · However, in this case, “Under Review” means that the paper was picked up for an initial review of the quality of the paper and of a match with the journal’s scope. On the occasion that a reviewer withdraws from the process, the Editorial Team will begin the reviewer selection process again. I have submitted an article to a JCR-indexed journal in November and in March, following the request of the journal, I submitted a revised version that contained changes to the introduction and literature review. You may then make your preliminary decision that will be sent to the Editor-in-Chief. ' I have heard from seniors that the EiC is only consulted for making acceptance-related decisions and that the AE gives [makes] other decisions. ) Peer review can take a few weeks or even months based on the topic and domain as well as on availability of the The next stage is editorial assessment: The editors decide whether the paper should enter the review process or should be rejected directly, e. But until now, 5/17, the status are still "awaiting decision". This is the stage that the editorial team will be striving to get your manuscript to as swiftly as possible. In the ‘worst’ case that this is a rejection decision, as you may know, you can submit to another journal, after making changes based on any feedback from this journal. He will then assign a AE or an academic editor who 2. One month from submission to final decision does seem quick, especially if it seems to have gone through a peer review, as indicated by the ‘Waiting for Reviewers’ Scores’ status. You can use: 1) Google translate from English to Turkish. Anyway, as yours was a minor revision, you probably don’t have much need to worry, which actually may be just the reason you wish to hear the decision on your paper. May 31, 2022 · Most journals normally take 4-8 weeks to review manuscripts. Editor Invited: This step is optional and may not occur in all journals. As you've mentioned, you have addressed the previous reviewer's concerns, so the EIC may suggest moving the manuscript to peer Sep 15, 2020 · The journal Electron Device Letters (EDL), as the name suggests, is for publishing letters, that is, shorter articles – about four pages long (including references), going by the description on the journal site. It has changed today from "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" to "Awaiting recommendation". What happens when you receive the decision letter? After peer review, the editor will consider feedback from the reviewers and then make a decision about the article. The fnal decision on a manuscript can be either acceptance with major or minor revisions or rejection. As the manuscript is now at the Awaiting EIC Decision stage, you should probably hear from the journal soon. You're at the "Editorial Decision" stage, and as you can see from there, the typical duration is a few workdays to a week. The Editor-in-Chief (EIC) may then do one of the following: Accept the EE’s decision. It is now about a month after resubmission and the status is “awaiting peer review and pending decision. But the best way to check this would be to go through the transfer section (if they have one) on the journal site. Answer: Thank you for your question. The majority of articles require revision before reaching this stage. Answer: It is difficult to estimate how much longer you need to wait. Hi. Since the reviews have come in, the AE should ideally not take Nov 11, 2020 · This would depend on how many journals the publisher has. After two revisions, the paper went under review. Upon submission, Editors will assess Apr 1, 2019 · The status of one of my manuscripts on ScholarOne is "ED: Not Assigned, GE: Not Assigned, Awaiting JM Checklist". So, your manuscript is awaiting a final decision. ) Anyway, here, ‘PE’ likely refers to the ‘Publishing Editor’ and therefore, the status refers to the decision by the Publishing Editor. Status shows "Revision submitted to journal". Oct 2, 2015 · 1 Answer to this question. The status "Awaiting AE assignment" implies that an editor will be assigned to handle the correspondence of your submitted manuscript. Your paper is evaluated by expert peers in the field, known as referees, with a publication decision made by the journal editors. ) A manuscript can have either an ED (AE) assigned or a GE, not both (unless this is for a special issue). Here the status could show "Editor assigned", or it could show "awaiting reviewer invitation". Feb 28, 2021 · My paper underwent a revision. Apr 20, 2020 · Today, there has been a status update on the journal's ScholarOne online portal which says "Awaiting SE Preliminary Decision". The editor in chief may not just 'accept' or 'reject' the manuscript. This allows the editor/admin to make a decision without sending the manuscript to review. IOP has a range of different decisions you could receive and these are outlined below. Decision Types. Answer: Such a quick change of statuses soon after submission usually means that the journal believes either that your manuscript isn’t working for them (for issues around the research or the paper) or that there’s no/low scope fit. May 6, 2021 · Your paper is resubmitted. The purpose of each flag is determined by the Journal’s editorial team. Jan 3, 2023 · 1 Answer to this question. The referees' reports may be sent to the authors for revision of the paper. The journal peer review process. Then in 3 weeks it was "awaiting reviewer reports" and yesterday finally "awaiting editorial decision". May 3, 2018 · How long one should wait on an editor's decision depends on a variety of factors - your stature within your profession, the quality of the journal to which you submitted the manuscript, and the Submitted manuscript awaiting recommendation - what does this mean? I submitted a revised manuscript (only a few changes requested) to a journal, and have been signing in periodically to see what the status is. Reject: The paper has been through the peer review process and the Action I submit my manuscript to IEEE WCL on 4/14/2019 (Minor revision). 4. On the same day, it turned again to "Awaiting reviewer scores. "Awaiting EIC decision" means that the journal is waiting on a decision by the "Editor in Chief". Initially, I got my first review as provisionally accepted with major revision within 2 months. The Editorial Team are in the process of finding suitable external expert reviewers that are available to review your article. Jul 11, 2017 · Hi everyone, I am a bit confused and wanted to bug you about something. com May 1, 2021 · The status “awaiting final decision after awaiting reviewer scores” means that the peer review has been completed and the reviewer comments have been sent back to the editorial office for assessment. After one week, I wrote to the Managing Editor enquiring about the status of my article, and he told me that he had received the needed reviews, and he is only waiting for the word of the Editor-in-Chief before he communicates the final Peer reviewers are given 2 weeks to submit their review of your article. 5. They will be responsible for evaluating the manuscript and checking that its scope matches with that of the journal. Now, it shows Awaiting Decision. “Awaiting Referee Scores” is a stage in the publication process where enough experts have agreed to read and evaluate a manuscript. As the status has already changed quite quickly here, the next decision may be updated shortly too. Is this common in scientific journals? I submitted others manuscripts to other journals and the review process was different. When you submit your paper to a journal, after the initial/basic administration check (for ‘hygiene factors’ such as adherence to journal guidelines), the manuscript goes to the Editor-in-Chief (EIC) for an assessment of the novelty and quality of the research/paper and, in some cases, even a match with Sep 30, 2019 · The graphic below shows how a typical manuscript goes through the Editorial Manager system, along with some of the terms used to describe the manuscript’s status. Now, the status is 'Awaiting EiC Decision. The status have been "With editor" since a month. So, this might be a rapid-publication journal. Just give it some time; either you will get a decision or it will go for the review process. Feb 9, 2020 · ‘Awaiting Editorial Office Processing’ means that the manuscript was awaiting an Editorial Office (EO) or Associate Editor (AE) check for aspects such as adherence to guidelines, match with the journal’s scope, and novelty of the study. On 4/26, the status on ScholarOne changed to awaiting decision. In case they don't, it won't hurt to ask these numbers. I submitted my manuscript via ScholarOne and within 2 days my status went from "editor assigned" to "under review". In this step, the editor carefully evaluates all the comments by the peer-reviewers and examines the manuscript. When you have submitted your paper or case study, up to three experts in the field will review it to provide validation, quality control and added value to you in the form of constructive feedback. The paper has been assigned Functional Ecology, Journal of Animal Ecology, Journal of Applied Ecology, Journal of Ecology, Methods in Ecology and Evolution, People and Nature, and Ecological Solutions and Evidence greatly appreciate the time and effort that all our reviewers dedicate to our review process. Completed - Accept/Reject Sep 28, 2020 · 1 Answer to this question. The status first showed as ‘ADM: a person’s name,’ and then as ‘Awaiting Referee Selection. " Oct 12, 2020 · I have submitted an article to a SAGE journal. Does this mean that the paper has passed the editorial check and the external reviewer completed? Awaiting Reviewer Selection Your article meets the Journal’s scope and has been approved for peer review. An Immediate Decision box may appear on in-process manuscripts depending on the site’s workflow. This decision should take into consideration your own opinion of the submission as well as the general consensus of the refereeing committee. After this, the manuscript usually goes through a formatting check by the journal staff before it is assigned to an editor. Most journals have an online manuscript tracking system that shows the manuscript’s current status. This is usually because of a scope mismatch, or in some cases, the novelty and/or quality of the research/paper not being Awaiting reviewers scores simply mean the article is with the reviewers and the journal office is waiting for the comments. Making Decisions. I have submitted my paper and the system is ScholarOne Manuscript. Jan 21, 2020 · Under Review: This means that the manuscript is presently under peer review. Nov 22, 2021 · Thank you for your question. (This may correspond to the Editor-in-Chief, or EIC Nov 17, 2023 · One role of the editor is to monitor the process and ensure that it is completed fairly and in a timely manner. Your article has now received the minimum number of reviews required to make a decision. So, why has it returned to the referee(s) after last week's status? The reviewers will have access to the original review details and the author’s appeal request. Nov 16, 2015 · Try to recollect how the statuses changed when you submitted the paper the first time. Decision types on journal articles. Oct 14, 2014 · 1. Completed - Accept/Reject Decision types on journal articles. Answer: “Final decision” does not necessarily mean rejection. The paper may be accepted in current form. Role of the Editor. In Manuscript Central, there were some changes of the paper’s status during the first two days, and as far as I can remember, these were Awaiting ADM Processing and Awaiting technical editor selection. ” Apr 23, 2018 · Hi all, I want to ask a quick question related to publication process. Understanding the Decision Process . After your article has been reviewed, you will receive an email with a first decision on the article. that are repeated every time a revised manuscript is submitted. The status changed to admin check to under review after one week. Aug 15, 2015 · I submitted my paper to a journal twelve days ago. ’ Is this likely to be a rejection – or can I still expect an acceptance? Meaning of journal status 'Awaiting Decision Approval' See full list on academia. At the third day, I saw Awaiting EE Decision which is still there. This means that the manuscript has been sent for peer review and the peer review has likely been completed, and now the journal is awaiting the final scores from the reviewer/s. The paper may be rejected. A final reason could be that the AE has changed, and the new AE thinks differently about your submission. The First look stage means that your manuscript, after an "Accept" decision is scrutinized to see if it adheres to journal standards (a. If it is not a desk reject, then it will surely go to the external peer-reviewers for review. However, now in August the status of the manuscript has remained "Awaiting EIC Aug 30, 2020 · Answer: The status ‘Awaiting Referee Selection’ typically means that the manuscript is awaiting peer review. Implies that the editors and reviewers feel the paper is publishable once their comments have Mar 25, 2016 · 1 Answer to this question. Nov 26, 2021 · 1 Answer to this question. May 25, 2020 · I submitted my paper in January. Across all Wolters Kluwer journals, the average time that a manuscript moves through the submission process from submission to first decision takes about 30 days, and to a final Nov 21, 2016 · But if your paper has not gone through peer review, and the status has changed directly from “With editor” to “Awaiting AE decision,” it could mean that your paper has been desk rejected. In the case of Option 2, the EE will provide a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief on the basis of the reviews submitted during the appeal. Once the completed reviews come in, the Associate Editor (AE) evaluates them and gives his recommendation to the EiC. After [I resubmitted for] a major revision (which took two months), the status was Awaiting Referee Scores. If you're wondering, there's a good chance the abnormal wait time is because there's more than one "editor-in-chief I have submitted my paper to one of the springer journal. Oct 24, 2020 · Once their recommendations are in, the AE will form their own opinion of their paper, involving the Editor-in-Chief (EIC) if needed, and then share the decision (called the first decision, unless the decision is to reject) with the author/s, through the next status update. Dear Bilal Ahmad The status 'Awaiting AE Recommendation' means that, based on the peer reviewer (or technical editor review, in this case), the AE is making a decision on the paper. 2) Trust me when I say that "Waiting approval" means: Onaylama bekleniyor. But if the publisher has decided on a transfer, they would have had an alternative journal in mind. stackexchange. It usually takes about a week or so. ’ Was an SAE assigned? Should I be worried about rejection? What is the SAE’s role here? Oct 8, 2015 · AE stands for Associate Editor. ti jf wi ov bw jt xs xs ao cg